Showing posts with label Robert Silverberg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Silverberg. Show all posts

Thursday, November 29, 2018

What would be an undeniable miracle?


In 1972, sci-fi writer and publisher Lester del Rey launched a challenge to three well-known authors of the genre: Poul Anderson, Robert Silverberg and Gordon R. Dickson. All three should write a novella on a specific topic: the effect of an undeniable miracle (the sun standing still) on human society. The three authors responded to the challenge, and the three stories were published jointly in a book entitled The day the sun stood still. In this post we shall consider the first of the three, written by Poul Anderson, whose title is A chapter of Revelation.
In a post in his blog, Pablo (a.k.a. sinopinionespropias) specifies which, in his opinion, should be the characteristics of an undeniable miracle:
1.      It must be a prophecy.
2.      Its materialization should not depend on people.
3.      Your probability must be negligible and calculable.
4.      It must be as concrete as possible.
5.      It must maintain the same demonstrative force with the passage of time.
6.      It must make sense at all times.