Blade Runner poster |
Lists of favorite
books have always existed, and with the rise of the Internet they have
proliferated. That’s why I decided to make a new list (in case there were not
enough). But what I’m showing here is not just the list of my favorite books in
this genre, but something a little more complex.
To build the list, I
started with four lists made by others, sometimes individually, sometimes
collectively. For example, one of those lists has been created in Goodreads,
the social network for books, is called Best Science Fiction and
contains over 2,000 books. In order to build this list, the members of Goodreads
vote (almost 1000 people have voted for at least one book), together with the book’s
score and the number of people who have read it (in some cases several
million).
To form my new list I
used the following criteria:
- It just
contains books that I have read.
- It
does not contain books that I have read, but did not like at all (i.e. those
I would assign one star in the Goodreads or Amazon ratings). As an example
of these books I will mention Do androids dream with electric sheep? by
Philip K. Dick. Its argument is based on an interesting idea, but the way
it has been developed in the form of a novel is deplorable, sometimes
absurd. This is one of the rare cases where the film based on a book (Blade Runner)
turned out to be far superior to the original work.
- Therefore,
if one of your favorite books is not listed here, it may be for three
reasons: because I have not read it, because I did not like it at all, or
because it didn’t come among the top 40 in the average of the lists I have
used to build mine.
- It only contains science fiction books. The Lord of the Rings, for example, has not been included, although it is on one of these lists, because I don’t consider it science fiction.
This is the resulting
list:
Or-der
|
Novel
|
Author
|
Or-der
|
Novel
|
Author
|
1
|
1984
|
George Orwell
|
21
|
Voyage au centre de la Terre
|
Jules Verne
|
2
|
Ender’s game
|
Orson Scott Card
|
22
|
Speaker for the dead
|
Orson Scott Card
|
3
|
Dune
|
Frank Herbert
|
23
|
A princess of Mars
|
Edgar Rice Burroughs
|
4
|
The Martian Chronicles
|
Ray Bradbury
|
24
|
The stars my destination
|
Alfred Bester
|
5
|
Foundation
|
Isaac Asimov
|
25
|
A canticle for Leibowitz
|
Walter M. Miller Jr.
|
6
|
2001 a space odyssey
|
Arthur C. Clarke
|
26
|
The caves of steel
|
Isaac Asimov
|
7
|
Randezvous with Rama
|
Arthur C. Clarke
|
27
|
Frankenstein
|
Mary Shelley
|
8
|
Fahrenheit 451
|
Ray Bradbury
|
28
|
A wrinkle in time
|
Madeleine L’Engle
|
9
|
The war of the worlds
|
H.G. Wells
|
29
|
War with the newts
|
Karel Capek
|
10
|
I robot
|
Isaac Asimov
|
30
|
The lathe of heaven
|
Ursula Le Guin
|
11
|
Starship troopers
|
Robert A. Heinlein
|
31
|
La invención de Morel
|
Adolfo Bioy Casares
|
12
|
The day of the triffids
|
John Wyndham
|
32
|
The Space Trilogy
|
C.S. Lewis
|
13
|
The time machine
|
H.G. Wells
|
33
|
Starship
|
Brian Aldiss
|
14
|
Brave new world
|
Aldous Huxley
|
34
|
A scanner darkly
|
Philip K. Dick
|
15
|
The left hand of darkness
|
Ursula Le Guin
|
35
|
Slaughterhouse-Five
|
Kurt Vonnegut
|
16
|
Flowers for Algernon
|
Daniel Keyes
|
36
|
Dr.Jekyll & Mr. Hyde
|
Robert Louis Stevenson
|
17
|
Solaris
|
Stanislaw Lem
|
37
|
Animal farm
|
George Orwell
|
18
|
The clockwork orange
|
Anthony Burgess
|
38
|
Flatland
|
Edwin Abbott
|
19
|
Hyperion
|
Dan Simmons
|
39
|
The ilustrated man
|
Ray Bradbury
|
20
|
20.000 lieues sous les mers
|
Jules Verne
|
40
|
We
|
Yevgeny Zamyatin
|
In this list the
following authors appear:
- Two are
represented by three novels: Isaac Asimov and Ray Bradbury.
- Six have
two novels: Orson Scott Card, Arthur C. Clarke, Ursula K. Le Guin, George
Orwell, Jules Verne and H.G. Wells.
- Twenty-two
with just a novel: Edwin Abbott, Brian Aldiss, Alfred Bester, Adolfo Bioy
Casares, Anthony Burgess, Edgar Rice Burroughs, Karel Capek, Philip K.
Dick, Robert A. Heinlein, Frank Herbert, Aldous Huxley, Daniel Keyes,
Stanislaw Lem , Madeleine L'Engle, CS Lewis, Walter M. Miller Jr., Mary
Shelley, Dan Simmons, Robert Louis Stevenson, Kurt Vonnegut, John Wyndham
and Yevgeny Zamyatin.
Walter M. Miller Jr. |
As for dates, this
list includes 7 books from the 19th century, 4 between 1900 and 1940, 18 of the
Golden Age of Science-Fiction (1940-1965) and 11 modern (1965-1990). Of the
last 27 years, there are none.
I repeat that this is not the list of my favorite books.
My personal preferences have only influenced by removing books from the list,
or changing the order slightly. As a comparison, I include here the list of my
favorite science fiction novels, excluding those I have written (:-):
Or-der
|
Novel
|
Author
|
Or-der
|
Novel
|
Author
|
1
|
A canticle for Leibowitz
|
Walter M. Miller Jr.
|
4
|
At the Earth’s core
|
Edgar Rice Burroughs
|
2
|
Orbit unlimited
|
Poul Anderson
|
Xenocide
|
Orson Scott Card
|
|
3
|
The caves of steel
|
Isaac Asimov
|
The sands of Mars
|
Arthur C. Clarke
|
|
The Martian Chronicles
|
Ray Bradbury
|
Randezvous with Rama
|
Arthur C. Clarke
|
||
Ender’s game
|
Orson Scott Card
|
Brave new world
|
Aldous Huxley
|
||
Perelandra
|
C.S. Lewis
|
The forgotten planet
|
Murray Leinster
|
||
4
|
Flatland
|
Edwin Abbott
|
Dark benediction
|
Walter M. Miller Jr.
|
|
Guardians of time
|
Poul Anderson
|
1984
|
George Orwell
|
||
I robot
|
Isaac Asimov
|
Comet dust
|
C.D. Verhoff
|
||
Foundation
|
Isaac Asimov
|
Voyage au centre de la Terre
|
Jules Verne
|
||
Fahrenheit 451
|
Ray Bradbury
|
20.000 lieues sous les mers
|
Jules Verne
|
||
The warrior’s apprentice
|
Lois McMaster Bujold
|
De la Terre a la Lune+Autour de la Lune
|
Jules Verne
|
||
A princess of Mars
|
Edgar Rice Burroughs
|
Short stories
|
H.G. Wells
|
It can be seen that
my list of favorite books has a greater granularity than the other lists I have
used. Essentially, I would give between 4.5 and 5 Goodreads stars to the six
books in places 1, 2 and 3; the other 20 would receive between 3.5 and 4.5
stars. 14 of my 26 favorite books of this genre are also in the previous list,
while 12 have been left out, so it can be said that my personal preferences didn’t
have a lot of influence on the other list.
Manuel Alfonseca
Happy 2018 for everyone
Happy 2018 for everyone
As a fan of Robert Heinlein, especially his juveniles, I'm sorry none of them made your list. Otherwise, great lists!
ReplyDeleteBut he made it! Look at number 11 in the first list.
DeleteRay Schneider means that non of his juveniles made it to the list. In any case, i think The Moon is a Harsh Mistress would be a better candidate. Starship Troopers though enjoyable isn't the best Heinlein has written.
ReplyDeleteIn the Goodreads list (the list with most voters I have used) "Starship troopers" is nr. 26 and "The moon is a harsh mistress" is nr. 34. Anyway the second book did not make my list, because I haven't read it (:-)
DeleteOf Heinlein's juveniles I liked a lot "The menace from Earth", but as this is a short story, it didn't make it to these two lists of novels.
"Moon" is way better than 'Troopers'! ...nd heinlein's juveniles are anything, but: 'The Star Beast'???? 'Time For the Stars'????'Red Planet' ??? 'Have Space Suit, Will Travel'??? Difficult to make ANY 'best SF'list, yer a brave man. :D
Delete