Thursday, April 28, 2022

Matter and antimatter. Why are we here?

The matter making the solar system, the Earth, all living beings and ourselves, is made up almost entirely of atoms which, in turn, are based on three elementary particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. For each of these particles, as well as for many others, not usually part of atoms, there is an antiparticle. Therefore, there could be antimatter antiatoms, made of antiprotons, antineutrons, and antielectrons (positrons).

An interesting property of matter and antimatter is that they cannot be together. As soon as they come into contact, they completely disintegrate, transforming into energy. Everything suggests that our galaxy (the Milky Way) is made up almost exclusively of matter. There is also some antimatter, in the form of antiparticle clouds, outside the galaxy, close to it and attracted by its gravity, but in such a small quantity, compared to the mass of the galaxy, that for practical purposes it can be ignored. It has also been said that there could be some (but very few) anti-stars.

Formerly it was believed that, just as there are galaxies of matter, there should be galaxies of antimatter in other regions of the universe. Human beings want to find symmetries everywhere. Therefore, if there is a lot of matter in the universe, there should also be a lot of antimatter: exactly the same amount. But then, when two galaxies collide with each other, if one of them were made of matter and the other of antimatter, they should disintegrate, and the consequent energy output would be so great that we could detect it. This has never been seen, even though there are many cases of colliding galaxies, some quite close to us, for the Andromeda galaxy is hurtling towards us and will collide with the Milky Way in a few billion years.

One possibility that has been proposed is that there are distinct regions in the universe. Although there seems to be nothing but matter in the entire visible universe, beyond the limit of our vision there could be regions dominated by antimatter, and so, on huge scales, there would be no asymmetry. This option is purely speculative, because it cannot be scientifically proven.

Today it is thought that it is very likely that the laws of physics are asymmetric, and that the amount of matter that was produced very close to the Big Bang was slightly greater than the amount of antimatter. Not very: for every billion atoms of antimatter there would have been just one more atom of matter (a billion plus one). When the billion atoms of antimatter disintegrated with the billion atoms of matter, one atom of matter would have been left over. From this would come all the atoms of matter making galaxies. There would therefore be no antimatter galaxies.

Where does the asymmetry come from? In fact, we don’t know, although various theories try to explain it.

  • Violation of CP symmetry: In some reactions between elementary particles, we don’t get the same result if the sign of the electric charge of the particles is changed (symmetry C, Charge) together with the right side and the left side (symmetry P, Parity). This asymmetry has been verified experimentally, which suggested to Isaac Asimov the title of one of his articles, and of the collection to which it belongs: The left hand of the electron. The problem is, for this asymmetry to explain the predominance of matter, more conditions should be met, such as that the principle of conservation of baryon number is not always obeyed. This means that the proton should decay over time, which has not been verified.
  • Existence of an anti-universe: According to this theory, the Big Bang would have given rise to the simultaneous appearance of two universes, one dominated by matter and the other by antimatter. Both together would be symmetric. One possible consequence is that there should be a large number of new particles, the superheavy sterile neutrinos, which could be the basis of dark matter. The bad news is that, until now, the existence of these neutrinos has not been demonstrated.
  • Antimatter could be hidden in dark matter: According to another theory, a hypothetical particle called Φ, which would have existed shortly after the Big Bang, before protons and neutrons appeared, could have decayed into a normal matter particle and a dark antimatter particle. Since we don't know what dark matter is, nothing else can be said about this theory.

There are other theories that try to solve the problem, but none of them go beyond the level of unproven hypothesis. Consequently, we must consider that the problem of the existence of matter in the universe has not been solved, for the time being. Along with dark matter and dark energy, this is one of the hardest remaining mysteries in contemporary physics.

The same post in Spanish

Thematic Thread about Standard Cosmology: Previous Next

Manuel Alfonseca

No comments:

Post a Comment