![]() |
| Poisson distribution of person names |
I enjoy compiling statistics on many things. Naturally, I also do it for this blog. One of the statistics I often compile is that of the names of people (scientists or otherwise) most frequently mentioned in the blog, which now has 564 posts. I presented such a table in January 2024, when 449 articles had been published, in the post titled Ten years of Divulciencia-Populscience, and I think it's time to update it. Here is the corresponding table, showing 40 people who have been mentioned at least 10 times.
|
Name |
Nr. posts |
Name |
Nr. posts |
|
Albert Einstein |
97 |
Werner Heisenberg |
18 |
|
Isaac Newton |
61 |
Julio Verne |
17 |
|
Jesucristo |
40 |
Roger Penrose |
17 |
|
Charles Darwin |
40 |
Nicolás Copérnico |
17 |
|
Stephen Hawking |
39 |
Kurt Gödel |
16 |
|
Aristóteles |
34 |
Arthur Eddington |
15 |
|
C.S. Lewis |
33 |
H.G. Wells |
14 |
|
Isaac Asimov |
33 |
Johannes Kepler |
13 |
|
Arthur C. Clarke |
27 |
Georg Mendel |
12 |
|
Alan Turing |
24 |
Aldous Huxley |
11 |
|
Richard Dawkins |
23 |
Niels Bohr |
11 |
|
Georges Lemaître |
22 |
James Maxwell |
11 |
|
Galileo Galilei |
21 |
Antoine de Lavoisier |
11 |
|
Platón |
20 |
Alvin Plantinga |
11 |
|
Claudio Ptolomeo |
20 |
G.K. Chesterton |
11 |
|
Max Planck |
19 |
Erwin Schrödinger |
10 |
|
Enrico Fermi |
19 |
Louis Pasteur |
10 |
|
Edwin Hubble |
19 |
Poul Anderson |
10 |
|
Ray Kurzweil |
19 |
Georges Gamow |
10 |
|
Teilhard de Chardin |
18 |
Stephen Jay Gould |
10 |
How did I get this table? Very simple: In my blog, I searched for each of the names and counted the number of blog posts in the answer. At some point, I thought that this task should be automatable with the tools we have, so I accessed the LLM associated with my blog and asked this question:
Make a
table with the names of the people mentioned in all the posts in
Diculciencia.blogspot.com and the number of posts in which each one appears,
containing people mentioned in at least 5 posts.
After “thinking” for a while, I got this answer:
Based on
the posts and extracts from the Divulciencia blog present in the sources…the
following people have been identified as mentioned in at least 5 different
posts.
|
Person name |
Number of posts |
|
Manuel Alfonseca |
20+ |
|
Albert Einstein |
6 |
|
Stephen Hawking |
5 |
|
Jesus Christ (Christ) |
5 |
|
Richard Dawkins |
5 |
Details on
the count and context:
- Manuel
Alfonseca: He appears in almost all of the articles from the sources,
either as an author's signature ("Posted by Manuel Alfonseca"),
in the headings of blog posts, or as a reference in the introduction to
his thematic threads and compilation books.
- Albert
Einstein: His mentions are distributed across posts on determinism
("The future is not written"), standard cosmology (in the
corresponding thematic thread), his famous "cosmological
constant" and its error, the measurement of gravity, and the debate
on physical causality.
Et cetera. As you can see, the results aren't
promising. Einstein appears 6 times, instead of 97. I suspect this is at least
partly because the LLM searched for “Albert Einstein” instead of “Einstein,”
which is what I searched for and appears many more times, as the full name
appears in 23 posts, considerably more than the 6 it found.
I asked the same question to GEMINI, and it
replied:
I'm a
text-based AI and can't help you with that.
I asked the same question to ChatGPT, and it
replied this:
I can't
reliably calculate mentions across all blog posts from here because the site
contains hundreds of entries (more than 450 in 2024 and around 550 in 2026),
and I don't have the full text of all of them to do a comprehensive count.
However,
the author himself published a table with the most cited people in the first
455 posts in Divulciencia. That table contains all the names that appeared at
least 10 times (therefore, they also meet the ≥5 occurrences criterion):
And then it showed me the table from my 2024 blog
post.
It seems that AI tools are not yet capable of
performing simple tasks, like what I asked. The closest one, for obvious
reasons, is that associated with the blog itself, but it's very unsatisfactory.
And GEMINI gave the most honest answer.
Thematic Thread on Anniversaries and Organization: Previous Next
Manuel Alfonseca
Have a good summer. See you on September 3rd

No comments:
Post a Comment